Top 5 Best Extra Firm Mattress Reviews 2020

The people’s increasingly growing inclination towards discovering the best extra firm mattress tells us something. Doesn’t it? For one thing, an extra firm mattress sure offers better reactive support to a large syndicate of conventional sleepers. From slightly overweight individuals and back-pain bearers to pain-free people that either sleep on their sides, back or stomach; a medium to extra firm mattress has proven to aid better sleep in people with varied body statistics and predominant sleeping positions.

Despite their proven superior benefits, choosing an extra firm mattress over some other apparently luxurious and comfortable plush mattress may require a great deal of pragmatic thinking, but you can’t get around it if value your long-term sleep health. If you’ve already come on terms with it and acknowledge that a firm mattress would invariably serve you better, we can help you narrow down your choices or even better, help you find the perfect one for your investment. So, without any further delay, here’s our list of the 5 best extra firm mattress that you’d hate to have overlooked.

Top 5 Best Extra Firm Mattresses

  • Existing users love it; people find the firmness of this mattress just right
  • High density layered foam construction makes for the optimal firmness to comfort ratio
  • Upper memory foam ensures no pressure point generation
  • Uses CertiPUR-US certified foam
  • Washable polyester cover
  • Available in all standard bed sizes
  • 10-year warranty
  • No trial period
  • Takes about 48 hours to completely inflate after unpacking

Zinus, among other mattress brands enjoys a trustworthy reputation among potential buyers. An augmented array of mattress selections with respect to firmness, materials conforming to elite certifications and eulogistic consumer reviews in congregation make for the brand’s prevalence across the states.

The Zinus Ultima Comfort mattress boasts incredible consumer acclamation on various online retail platforms. The mattress is ultra-firm and ranks at around 6-7 on the firmness scale. To put the number in context, the 12-inch mattress provides optimal reactive support corresponding to the sleeper’s bodyweight. This further makes it suitable for couples that have a considerable difference in their individual bodyweights.

Now, the key to select a good mattress is to ensure that it isn’t too firm nor too soft. The middle ground is where sustainable comfort lies. If your mattress turns out too firm, it may start to generate pressure points along your spine, shoulders and hips. This mattress in our opinion combines the right proportions of firmness and softness to help you experience both; ideal counteractive support and a comfortable sleeping surface.

The 12-inch mattress is layered with a thick 6” base layer of high-density foam. The firmness of a mattress comes from this base layer. The thicker and denser the base foam layer, the firmer will be the overall feel of the mattress. As for this one, the base foam layer accounts for a medium to high firmness. The other two layers measuring 3-inches each account for adequate ventilation and superficial comfort. The top 3” premium memory foam layer gives the mattress its aspect of comfort. The combined construction overall makes for an extra firm yet pleasant sleeping surface.

  • Very firm mattress feel; ideal for overweight or back pain sufferers
  • Compatible with all bed frames and bases
  • No chemical off-gassing
  • Inflates quickly; serves right after unpacking
  • 10 year warranty
  • The mattress is too firm; might just be uncomfortable for slim people
  • No foam or fabric certifications highlighted

Higher up the firmness scale, this 12-inch mattress has an optimised cross section with an even thicker base foam layer accounting for increased reactive support. Precisely, the mattress section reveals a 10” green tea ventilated high density foam underlain by a 2” Gel infused memory foam. The ratio here clearly adds up to a firmer feel that you could rate at around 8 on the firmness scale of 1-10, 10 being the firmest. To give you a first-hand impression, here’s what a top-rated review on Amazon says: “the mattress is very firm as I wanted. My sleep definitely improved; my wife loves it.

For the price, the mattress offers great value in all respects. Some benefits that you can expect from investing in this extra-firm mattress are improved spine support, a sturdy yet cool sleeping surface and deep sleep undisturbed form your partner’s movements.

The mattress is made from hypoallergic foam, meaning it doesn’t attract potential allergens including dust, pollen and pet dander; perfect super firm mattress for allergy sufferers. However, despite the foam feeling sturdy, durable and great on the back, the foam isn’t CertiPUR-US certified. This might put some our readers off, but again, for the price, the mattress is a pretty good deal.

  • CertiPUR-US certified foam
  • Thick high-density base foam layer gives you a medium to highly firm feel
  • Removable quilted cover
  • Top 2” foam layer is infused with a cooling gel
  • Fully inflates in just under 24 hours
  • 10 years warranty
  • No trial period

Not uncomfortably firm, this 10-inch mattress from Sealy, according to us is the perfect option for people with average to moderately high bodyweight. Peaking at around 6-7 on the firmness scale, this is a more desirable firmness range for a larger group of people other than obese individuals.

The mattress section reveals a typical multilayered assembly. With a 5” high density base foam layer to provide counteractive support against the sleeper’s weight, the mattress feels pretty firm for the average sleeper. The upper layers gradually reduce in density to account for adequate comfort besides the inherent firmness. The top 2” layer is a responsive memory foam infused with a trademarked cooling technology termed as CopperChill.

The overall construction of the mattress builds up to an adequately firm yet comfortable and cool sleeping surface. Above all, the foam used in the mattress is CertiPUR-US certified indicating pristine quality and durability. The mattress is packed to be accommodated very well inside a box and after unpacking, inflates completely within 24 hours.  

The mattress unlike some cheaper alternatives has a commendable edge support. This implies that the mattress doesn’t sag with use. This is also reflected in the hefty 10 year warranty.

  • Highly economical
  • Very firm mattress feel owing to the thick base foam layer
  • Compatible with any bed base
  • CertiPUR-Us certified foam
  • 10 year warranty
  • Takes more than 2 days to fully inflate and come to regular size

In at number 4, Early bird is another highly economical series of extra firm memory foam mattresses that despite being relatively cheap, maintains top-notch quality and assured durability. The CertiPUR-US certified foam used in the layered assembly of each of the 6-inch, 8-inch and 10-inch variants in this range offer comparable comfort and reactive support.

As desired, the mattress is assembled with two foam layers, both having different densities conforming to elite level certification. The base layer accounts for the majority of the reactive support and by extension, the ultra-firm feel of the mattress. The upper foam layer is considerably thinner with lower density ensuring adequate room for movements. The top foam layer is also infused with gel, making the mattress surface cooler than standard mattresses.

The mattress, as desirable, is compatible with a variety of base beds. You can place the mattress on the floor, a box spring or an adjustable bed. The assembly further facilitates better ventilation which in combination with the cool gel layer makes for zero warmth retention. Overall, a very budget option that’s still at par with industry leading mattresses as far as quality is concerned.

  • Compatible with all bed bases
  • Can be customised with different available bed frames
  • Foam certified with CertiPur-US
  • 7” high density base layer provides a highly firm feel
  • Ideal for all sleeping positions
  • 10 year warranty
  • Not the best edge support

Extremely popular among people preferring a rather firm mattress, the Vibe 12-inch mattress is another neat alternative for you to consider if you want your purchase to comply with reputable certifications. Alongside, you’ve got a lot of options to consider and customise your purchase if you’re looking to purchase a new bed with the mattress.

Proving its compatibility with a variety of base beds, the mattress is sold by the seller with optional frame beds and adjustable beds. Quality wise, the mattress leaves no room for improvement. The foam used in its layered assembly complies with CertiPUR-US. The mattress achieves to give the sleeper a medium to highly firm reaction based on their weight with the help of a multi-layered construction.

The 7” base layer, as ideal, is a high-density certified foam that holds accountability for adequate reactive support, the upper layers have their densities adjusted to provide suitable comfort in addition to the firm overall feel of the mattress. To summarize, the top layer conforms to your body contours while the bottom layer keeps your spine position intact in any sleeping position. Above all, the mattress has a 10-year warranty, so you can pretty much tell how durable the mattress will actually be.

Best Extra Firm Mattress - Buying Guide

What Qualifies as an Extra Firm Mattress?

1Extremely softThese are richly luxurious mattress that offers the vibe of “sinking in”
2-3SoftThese are soft by nature and are embedded by “sinking in” quality
4-6MediumThese mattresses are luxurious but feature less “sinking in” quality
7-9FirmThese are comparatively harder and offer limited sinking and soft sensation
10Super FirmThese are extremely hard and don’t include any plushness, soft or sinking quality.

The firmness of a mattress is typically appraised on the numerical scale of 1-10. The mattress that seems medium-firm to you may feel hard for someone else as everyone has their preferences. Numerous factors need to be considered incorporating body mass index (BMI), sleep position, physical sensitivity, whether you feel hot in a certain position during sleep and if you sleep alone or with your partner.

Even though firmness is about your impression of solace, mattress manufacturers rate products following the numeric scale. The numbers make the customers understand the firmness or softness of a mattress in a better way. The rankings range from extremely soft to extremely firm along this generic scale:

If you are in search of an extra firm mattress, then you can go with the rating of around 7-9.

Is an Extra Firm Mattress the Best Choice For You?

The firmness of a mattress is not same for every person. What feels extremely firm to you might not feel that firm for any other individual who is heavier than you as weight is also one of the crucial aspects to consider. There are a lot of factors that should influence your decision including your sleeping positions, health and age considerations and your personal preferences as well. If your bed is not firm enough and you experience soreness once you get out of it, then your bed might be the problem for you. So, explore all these factors and make an ideal choice.

Extra Firm Mattress are Ideal for:

1. People with Back pain

Most of the people suffer from severe back pain which can be caused due to bad posture, prolonged sitting or sleeping on the wrong mattress. People who sleep on soft mattresses experience back pain more often than the ones who sleep on a medium-firm or extra firm mattress. The reason being that the soft mattress allows your body to sink into the bed making your spine to fall out of alignment during the sleep which leads to major pain. On the other hand, firm mattress has a more stable and even surface that offers superior support to the spine and hampers it from sinking into the bed while maintaining its natural alignment.

2. Overweight Individuals

Heavy individuals tend to feel the core or base foam of the mattress more due to the increased level of pressure created by their body weight on the mattress. Therefore, if they choose to have a soft mattress, they will experience more sinking following their body curves and misalignment of their spine. It can develop joint pain and back pain as well.That’s why they are advised to choose the firm mattress as it creates an opposite effect and offers less or no sinkage at all. It offers superior support to the back and restricts their body to descend into the bed.

3. Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers make up about 16% of the resting populace and usually need a firmer mattress. Soft mattress tends to sink their abdomen and also misalign the natural position of the spine. Moreover, sleeping on stomach creates pressure on the internal organs and doesn’t offer an adequate support to the spine and neck, which can lead to acute pain in the neck and back. Therefore, a firm mattress works best for them as the even surface keeps the spine in alignment and hence eliminates the neck and back issues.

4. Back Sleepers

Only 10% to 15% of individuals prefer to sleep on their back as for many people it is not the comfortable sleeping position. It can cause pain in the lower back but not with the ideal mattress. A medium firm mattress suits best for back sleepers as it offers an optimum support to the “S” curve of the spine while being stiff to support the upper back. If there is a gap between your lumbar region and the mattress, then you can put a small pillow under your knees. This will help you in eliminating the gap and hence maintains the right alignment of your spine along with the surface of the mattress. 

Extra Firm Mattress might be Inconvenient for:

1. Underweight Individuals

Individuals who fall in the underweight category tends to feel the top layer of the mattress more as compared to the core foam material. There are higher chances that they find firm mattress uncomfortable as they don’t weigh enough to feel that sink-in sensation. The people with a Body Mass Index of less than 18.5 are considered to be underweight. They are recommended to opt for a plush mattress that ranges around 1-3 in terms of firmness points. It offers an optimum softness so that the body of underweight people can sink into the bed and gets the utmost comfort.

2. Side Sleepers

Sleepers who sleep on their sides don’t generally stay similarly situated. A ton of times they pivot from the two legs straight, to one straight and one twisted, to both bowed. With this consistent change, side sleepers need a mattress with delicate to medium level firmness, normally something in the range of 3-6. A soft mattress with a great level of support will alleviate pressure points on your neck and back. 

Firmness and feel are amazingly significant for side sleepers as they need a mattress that is sufficiently delicate enough to contour to their body curves. A mattress that is too firm will not form in the state of the side sleeper, causing lack of comfort and support that generally make pressure points driving toward neck pain, back pain and shoulder pain.

3. Older People

Old people do not get that comfort level from a very firm mattress as their joints, muscles and bones deserve a plush mattress which is soft and featured with sink in effect. The mattresses that range around 3-4 might work best for some senior people, but they might not be suitable for the ones who are affected by certain medical conditions like arthritis and other joint problems. They require a combination of support and comfort and mattress that ranges between 5-6 on the firmness scale will be more suitable to them.

How to Select the Best Extra Firm Mattress

1. Material

Innerspring and foam are the two most prevalent materials used in the manufacturing of a mattress. Innerspring comprises of bunches of metal curls suspended in different materials of the mattress. They offer a great comfort, especially for heavier individuals or those with back disorders, but they are often short lived. On the other hand, foam mattresses are integrated with multiple layers of different densities of foam that offer the ideal firmness. The foam molds around the contours of the body and offers a great comfort. Moreover, it comes with a service life measured in decades, which is a plus point. You can read our comparison article about Innerspring vs Foam Mattress

2. Layered Cross Section

Innerspring and foam are the two most prevalent materials used in the manufacturing of a mattress. Innerspring comprises of bunches of metal curls suspended in different materials of the mattress. They offer a great comfort, especially for heavier individuals or those with back disorders, but they are often short lived. On the other hand, foam mattresses are integrated with multiple layers of different densities of foam that offer the ideal firmness. The foam molds around the contours of the body and offers a great comfort. Moreover, it comes with a service life measured in decades, which is a plus point. 

3. Flippable or Non-Flippable

Some brands offer flippable mattress featuring suitable sleep surfaces on both the sides to accommodate sleepers, whose preferences vary from night to night. on the hand, some offer the same kind of firmness on both the sides. If you experience recurring phases of back ache, then you should opt for a mattress that is medium firm on one side and extra firm on the other side so that you can flip the mattress whenever you want to adjust the feel. Moreover, flipping of a mattress also enhances its lifespan and anticipates significant sink-in as well. 

4. Trial Period

Some brands offer flippable mattress featuring suitable sleep surfaces on both the sides to accommodate sleepers, whose preferences vary from night to night. on the hand, some offer the same kind of firmness on both the sides. If you experience recurring phases of back ache, then you should opt for a mattress that is medium firm on one side and extra firm on the other side so that you can flip the mattress whenever you want to adjust the feel. Moreover, flipping of a mattress also enhances its lifespan and anticipates significant sink-in as well. 

5. Warranty

The contentious market of the mattress industry is surely compelling brands to elongate their warranty periods. Some brands even offer a 10 year warranty to attain the customer confidence as it shows that the brand is confident about its product’s manufacturing. Therefore, before making a purchase, you should compare the warranty periods of separate brands. However, longer warranty periods may translate to a higher price point. So, go for the ones that have got an authentic warranty period along with suitable price that fits into your budget as you can’t just rely on the warranty alone.

Conclusion

High-quality sleep is critical for our physical and mental well-being. At present times, people live such busy lives that they neglect their bodily needs. Depriving your body of adequate rest can eventually add up to severe conditions. Although we can’t control all life’s stress inducing factors, but there are some factors we can manipulate to our favour.

Switching to a comfortable extra firm mattress is one of them! Giving your body a relaxing and comforting sleeping surface can drastically improve your sleeping pattern. Even if the sleeping disorder is caused because of back pains, there are specific mattresses for the condition. Once, you get the right mattress for you, hardly you would want to use your screens in the night time. We really hope this article helped you in making the right choice.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment

Recent Posts